- Dim The Lights
- Posts
- xQc and H3H3's Clash Over Reacting to YouTube Videos
xQc and H3H3's Clash Over Reacting to YouTube Videos
Curated news for streamers and content creators
DimTheLights
August 15, 2023 • Estimated Reading Time: 9 minutes
Thanks for subscribing for free to the Dim The Lights Newsletter. If you’d like to support me, consider joining my Ko-Fi or making a one-time donation.
xQc debating Ethan Klein (H3H3 Podcast)
Engaging Debate in the Streaming Community: xQc and H3H3's Clash Over Reacting to YouTube Videos
In a recent live broadcast, the dynamic landscape of content creation took center stage as popular Twitch streamer xQc found himself in a spirited debate with H3H3's Ethan and Hila Klein. The topic under scrutiny was the practice of streamers reacting to YouTube videos, a subject that has sparked considerable controversy.
The heart of the matter lies in whether this style of content engagement is a form of content "theft." xQc, known for his marathon streaming sessions often featuring YouTube-react content, defended the approach, emphasizing his intention to support lesser-known creators and create positive outcomes. On the other side, Ethan contended that the primary beneficiaries are the streamers themselves, who potentially divert attention and earnings from the original video creators.
xQc originally received criticism from Mutahar with this tweet below.
Just a shame garbage like this fills the recommended tab.
— Mutahar (@OrdinaryGamers)
11:48 PM • Jul 28, 2023
Mutahar’s criticism sparked an ongoing barrage of tweets from Mutahar and xQc attempting to 1-up each other. Of course, many other content creators chimed in to share their thoughts on react content including Ethan Klein, who put xQc on blast. In typical xQc fashion, he invited Ethan to debate the issue.
I'd like to say publicly that @xQc is a content thief, and if you think that is defamation PLEASE sue me bitch. Destroying morons in court is my favorite hobby. And if you want me to explain why you are content thief, I'm happy to chat with you anytime.
— Ethan Klein (@h3h3productions)
4:33 AM • Aug 4, 2023
The debate grew intense during their conversation, with xQc's animated responses adding to the drama. Despite the fervent exchange, a consensus remained elusive, leaving the discussion unresolved.
The divide between these two perspectives is not a novel one. Content creators, especially larger ones like PewDiePie, have faced criticism for employing this format, accused of repackaging existing content with minimal value addition. This controversy raises important questions about ethical content usage and its impact on content creators' livelihoods.
Ethan highlighted an ethical alternative in the realm of react content. He shared insights from a YouTube creator who acknowledged streamers like Hasan, who actively promote the original content by directing their subscribers to the creators' channels. However, this practice wasn't attributed to xQc.
The crux of this discourse centers on whether larger content creators unintentionally overshadow smaller creators by reusing their content without appropriate acknowledgment or promotional efforts. The tension reached its peak during the debate, even leading to xQc resorting to expressive emotes to underscore his points.
Ultimately, the conversation ended without a clear resolution. Ethan, perhaps sensing a deadlock, concluded the call. This event underscores the ongoing conversation within the streaming community about fair content usage, collaboration, and the balance between individual creativity and communal respect.
What do you think about content usage and xQc’s arguments in defense of his approach to react content? Would love to hear your thoughts in the weekly poll down below!
📊WEEKLY POLL📊
Have you listened to the recent react content debate between xQc and Ethan Klein?
It isn't a new debate, but cycles every so often.
Our latest newsletter poll asks streamers "Do you believe xQc's react content is considered stealing?" 👇
— Dim🇵🇷🇪🇨 Streamer News (@DimTheLightsTTV)
2:44 AM • Aug 15, 2023
SPONSORED
Current Deals
Twitch News
Last week Twitch launched Featured Clips aiming to increase discoverability on its platform. You can now see how your Featured Clips are performing in the Analytics > Overview tab in your Creator Dashboard.
STREAMERS BEWARE: Compromised Twitch Partner accounts are posting suspicious links. Do not click on them.
Twitch launches its Chat Countdown Timer to help streamers and viewers better understand and manage ad breaks.
The next Twitch Rivals showdown will show creators compete in Marvel Snap
YouTube News
YouTube teases new features including Vertical Live Streaming, Shorts Remixing, and resources on Fan Funding.
YouTube shares insights on how creators are getting in on the #Barbie trends.
YouTube is disabling live links in Shorts to reduce an increase in spam.
Ever wonder how the YouTube algorithm works? Rene Ritchie explains!
Kick News
Depite having 3mil followers on Twitch, SapNap moves to Kick.
Kick announces a bunch of new updates coming to the platform soon.
Kick now supports payments through Paypal.
Kick announces the First Class of the Kick Creator Incentive Program set to offer this group of streamers an hourly wage.
YourRage joins Kick and signs to FaZe Clan.
TikTok warns creators to disclose their ai-generated content.
Instagram Threads introduces six new features including tracking likes, sending threads as DMs, sorting follower lists, and more.
You can now add music to photo carousels on Instagram
Gaming News
The U.S. Supreme Court declined to allow a judge to force Apple to change its App Store payment rules; dealing a serious blow to Epic Games in its legal fight with Apple.
Overwatch 2’s Steam Launch was met with negative reviews.
TMNT fans are hyped after the official teaser trailer for the TMNT Last Ronin video game was released.
Looks like we are getting a Valorant movie and the teaser is set to release in October 2024
Creator Chatter
YouTubeLiason offers some advice to streamers who are discourage by a decrease in YouTube engagement.
Kai Cenat expresses disappointment in the chaos that broke out during his giveaway event in New York City (covered in a previous newsletter).
YouTuber Kwebbelkop replaces himself with an AI avatar to takeover his channel with 15 million followers.
HyperX is looking for the next big Creator.
JacksFilms criticizes Snnniperwolf for her “lazy” approach to react content.
Reply